In Brazil, adults move more during their leisure time than they did fifteen years ago, but less for getting around. Between 2009 and 2023, the share of those meeting the recommended threshold for physical activity during their free time rose from 30 to 41%, while the share achieving this same threshold by walking or cycling to get somewhere fell from 17.0% in 2009 to 10.4% in 2021, according to the Brazilian Ministry of Health. The trends concern two distinct domains of physical activity and can justify complementary interventions.

The essentials

  • In Brazil, sufficient leisure-time physical activity increased by 6.4 percentage points between 2009 and 2021, but activity related to commuting declined by five percentage points over the same period (Ministério da Saúde, Vigitel: analysis of physical activity trends between 2009 and 2023).
  • The trends point to distinct domains that may require complementary interventions.
  • Walking and cycling daily can be accessible forms of physical activity for those who lack the time or resources to play sports.
  • When urban design makes walking less viable, less motorized groups risk seeing their daily physical activity decline, which could contribute to health inequalities.
  • Latin America has concrete examples—Bogotá, Curitiba, Buenos Aires—demonstrating that alternative planning is possible.

Two curves, two policies

The Brazilian data deserves closer examination. The Vigitel survey has tracked health behaviors among adults in state capitals across the country since 2006. It distinguishes four domains of physical activity: what people do during leisure time—sport, walking, deliberate activity; what they accumulate by walking or cycling to work, school, or to take someone to school; occupational activity and domestic tasks.

These two measures have evolved in opposite directions over fifteen years. The first rises steadily. The second declines just as steadily. The opposite trends in the two domains are established, but their possible compensation cannot be inferred from these prevalence figures alone, since the populations concerned only partially overlap.

The person who runs on Sunday in a park and the person who walks forty minutes each morning to catch the bus generally do not combine their activity levels. The latter is often employed, constrained by work schedules, and has no time slots for sports. His only regular physical activity is the commute. When the city sprawls, when public transit moves farther away, when the sidewalk disappears or becomes unusable, that commute happens by moto-taxi or direct bus. And daily movement evaporates.

The rise in sports leisure hides a retreat in active commuting

The increase in leisure-time activity is a real success. Sports promotion policies in Latin America have borne fruit: renovated parks, pistas de caminhada (walking and jogging tracks), free municipal physical activity programs. São Paulo, Belo Horizonte, and Fortaleza have invested in these facilities since the 2000s. The results are visible in the numbers.

But this progress masks a structural inequality. Access to sports during leisure time requires available free time, a safe environment, and often equipment or registration fees. These conditions are generally less often met in urban peripheries, favelas, and popular neighborhoods than in central areas. Public health studies conducted in Latin America suggest that leisure-time physical activity rates tend to increase more among middle and upper classes than among working-class populations.

Activity related to commuting, conversely, was historically more prevalent among lower-income workers. Vigitel confirms a sharper decline in active commuting among people with less education, but does not allow us to demonstrate the actual health consequences or characterize their motorization. The result is a divergence: more educated people have progressed more in leisure activity, while active commuting has declined chiefly among those with less education.

Urban sprawl as involuntary health policy

Latin American cities have undergone notable territorial expansion over the past thirty years. São Paulo today covers an area comparable to Los Angeles, with density collapsing as one moves away from the center. Lima, Bogotá, and Santiago have experienced similar dynamics. A significant share of new residential zones are designed primarily for automobile circulation. Distances between home, work, and services tend to increase, reducing the viability of walking.

This urbanization model has direct effects on health, even when no one deliberately chose them. These characteristics of the built environment are associated with active commuting, without demonstrating a strong causal effect on their own. The city then has a de facto health policy, unfavorable, without ever having formulated it as such.

The relationship between urban form and physical activity has been documented since the 1990s in public health research. What is new is the ability to measure it over long series in middle-income countries. The Brazilian Vigitel data offers exactly that: tracking of 27 urban units, with active commuting data from 2009 to 2021 and an analytical distinction between the two activity sources. They allow us to see what sports policies do not see: what happens when people come home from work.

Experiences showing an alternative trajectory is possible

Several Latin American cities have implemented active urban planning policies with documented results.

Bogotá launched the Ciclovía in 1974: every Sunday and public holiday, the Ciclovía currently opens 141.46 kilometers of routes interconnected for pedestrians and cyclists. The Ciclovía serves more than 1.5 million users per week. Several studies document that the Ciclovía generates significant physical activity at the population level. The city extended the experiment by developing its permanent cycle path network, the ciclorrutas, which now covers over 550 kilometers. These infrastructures are dedicated to daily commuting, not leisure.

Curitiba, in southern Brazil, has built since the 1970s a public transportation system organized around rapid corridors that require users to walk to access stations. The city has also integrated linear parks along its urban drainage corridors, creating pedestrian continuities across the city. In 2021, Curitiba’s active commuting level was 9.0%, below the average for Brazilian capitals (10.4%), a gap explained as much by urban design as by transportation policy.

Buenos Aires has developed since 2010 an active mobility policy that significantly increased its cycle path network and launched a bike-sharing system. Argentina’s Observatorio Social del Deporte tracks physical activity among children and adolescents and documents the effects of these policies on behaviors. Results remain uneven across neighborhoods, but the direction is clear.

These three cities are not examples of perfection. Bogotá remains very violent in certain neighborhoods, limiting use of cycle paths at night. Curitiba has experienced peripheral expansion that dilutes the benefits of its transportation model. Buenos Aires concentrates its investments in northern neighborhoods, already advantaged. But they show that a city can deliberately choose to make daily movement easier, and that this choice has effects on its population’s health.

Today’s urban choices will determine who moves in 2040

If the trend continued, it could justify monitoring health inequalities linked to physical activity.

Physical inactivity is an important risk factor, among others, for type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and certain cancers. The WHO recommends 150 minutes of moderate physical activity per week for an adult. In Brazilian state capitals, a portion of the population was meeting this physical activity threshold largely through commuting. When this mechanism disappears, the health burden could increase for public health systems.

Available data describe past trends and qualitative scenarios, but do not allow us to assert the existence of two urban trajectories toward 2040. A first scenario assumes continuation of the current model: urban sprawl, dependence on private vehicles or motorcycles, insufficient pedestrian infrastructure. In this case, leisure activity would likely progress more in middle and upper classes, while commuting activity would show contrasting patterns by country and education level. This divergence would call for complementary policies on mobility, urban planning, and physical activity.

A second scenario assumes deliberate change in urban form: densification, functional mix bringing together home, work, and services, investment in transportation networks that require walking to access stations, continuous and secure cycle infrastructure. In this case, activity related to commuting would have a better chance of stabilizing or increasing for populations most in need.

The choice between the two trajectories is not technical. It is political and financial. Cities that chose the second—Bogotá, Curitiba, and to some extent Mexico with its streetcar and active mobility policy—did so because mayors arbitrated in favor of public space over automobile space, in favor of density over sprawl, in favor of walking over cars. These choices have opponents: real estate developers who prefer to build on the periphery, automakers, individual transport lobbies.

Indicators used by cities seeking to reverse the trend

The most useful signal to track in the coming years is cities’ capacity to develop measurement tools for activity related to commuting. The Brazilian Vigitel data are an exception at the regional level: few Latin American countries have such a long and well-constructed series. Argentina, with its Observatorio Social del Deporte, is beginning to develop comparable tools for children and adolescents. But systematic measurement of adult physical activity from commuting remains rare.

Without measurement, there is no political accountability. A mayor who launches a cycle path program without knowing whether they are being used, and by whom, cannot defend results or target investments. Cities that equip themselves with active mobility indicators—kilometers traveled on foot and by bike per capita, cycle path use by neighborhood, average walking time to reach a transit stop—are those that can steer health policy through urban planning.

The WHO has developed frameworks for evaluating physical activity at the city level. Several European and North American metropolises use them. Their adoption in Latin America remains limited. This is a concrete angle of action for national governments and international organizations that fund public health policies in the region.

The question posed by the Brazilian data is ultimately quite simple. Leisure-time physical activity increased in Brazil between 2009 and 2023; Vigitel does not allow us to attribute it to specific investments or programs. But the opposite trends suggest an issue of coherence in urban and sports policies. Prevention of chronic diseases can benefit from joint action on leisure-time physical activity and active commuting, among other determinants, and from understanding that the shape of a neighborhood is also a public health decision.


Sources

  1. Brazilian Ministry of Health, Vigitel Brasil 2006-2023: physical activity practice
  2. Observatorio Social del Deporte de Argentina, Survey on Sport and Physical Activity in Children and Adolescents (source without verified URL)
  3. World Health Organization, Global Recommendations on Physical Activity for Health, who.int
  4. Prefeitura de Bogotá, documentation on the Ciclovía and ciclorrutas, bogota.gov.co
  5. Urban Research and Planning Institute of Curitiba (IPPUC), data on the transportation system and linear parks, ippuc.org.br