In 2023, 32.9% of Brazilian municipalities provide contradictory answers to two national surveys on the existence of selective waste collection. In 2023, 1,837 municipalities, representing 32.9% of the total, provided contradictory responses to two different national surveys on this single question, according to the Brazilian Institute of Applied Economic Research (Ipea). This figure does not measure an industrial lag. It measures a data governance failure that precedes everything else: the absence of harmonized indicators limits data comparability and the precision of diagnoses necessary for public action.
The essentials
- In 2023, 32.9% of Brazilian municipalities provide contradictory answers about the existence of selective collection according to the two national databases (Sinisa and IBGE survey), according to Ipea.
- Sinisa recorded only a formalized service in 29.3% of municipalities in 2022, while Munic shows a higher rate, revealing a divergence between the two sources.
- The divergence stems from an inconsistent definition: a voluntary collection container and an organized supply chain with sorting and traceability are treated as the same legal category of selective collection.
- The absence of data harmonization complicates comparison and diagnosis, without making them impossible in principle.
- Several emerging economies are working on frameworks for territorial certification of collection service levels to harmonize measurements and improve financing.
A drop-off point is not a supply chain
Brazil has two instruments to measure waste management at the municipal level. Sinisa, the National System of Information on Sanitation, collects declarations from service operators. Munic, an annual survey by the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE) of city halls, collects declarations from local administrations. The two address different interlocutors across different scopes. So far, nothing unusual.
The difficulty appears when one compares their answers to the same question: the existence of selective collection in a given municipality. Across 1,837 municipalities, the two sources diverge. In some cases, Sinisa indicates yes and Munic indicates no; in others, the reverse. Ipea mapped these inconsistencies across the entire territory in 2023.
The result reveals a massive blind spot: nearly one-third of the municipalities compared have contradictory data between Sinisa and Munic.
The main cause lies in the definition used. Brazilian law on the national solid waste policy makes no distinction between a voluntary collection container placed in a supermarket parking lot and an organized supply chain with sorting, weighing, traceability, and certified industrial outlet. Both formally satisfy the question of the existence of selective collection.
29.3%: the Sinisa figure versus municipal declarations
Sinisa, which relies on field operators, recorded in 2022 a formalized selective collection service in 29.3% of Brazilian municipalities. The Munic survey for the same period shows a substantially higher rate, because city halls more readily declare the existence of a service, however minimal.
The gap between the two measures is not a methodological detail. It indicates that declarations and surveys produce divergent results whose correspondence with the reality of the service is incomplete. A mayor who has installed three voluntary sorting containers in the city center can legitimately answer “yes” to the Munic survey. The collection operator, meanwhile, knows that these containers are not emptied on a dedicated circuit, that the materials do not go to a recovery supply chain, and that no tonnage data is produced. They sometimes answer differently, or not at all.
The result: two national databases, financed by the federal government, that produce incompatible images of the same territory. And a public decision-maker who cannot know which to believe.
Blind indicators according to Diane Coyle
Economist Diane Coyle developed in The Measure of Progress (2025) a thesis directly applicable to this case. Our statistical instruments inherit conceptual decisions made at another time, for other purposes. When the economy changes, or when policy shifts objectives, indicators do not automatically follow. They continue to measure what they have always measured, using the categories they have always used. Public management then operates on a distorted image, without anyone in the system necessarily committing an error.
Brazil illustrates this mechanism with rare precision. The legal framework of the national solid waste policy set ambitious circularity objectives. The instruments were revised, but Ipea notes that their harmonization and standardization remain insufficient. The Brazilian state has coverage measures, but cannot determine with certainty whether the observed variations correspond to a real expansion of supply chains or to changes in declarations.
Coyle poses the question as a political prerequisite: if we cannot manage what we do not measure correctly, indicator reform is a condition of the reform itself, not a technocratic luxury. The situation in Brazil illustrates that investment in measurement and standardization is a prerequisite for the effectiveness of infrastructure investments.
The institutionalists: who benefits from ambiguity
A complementary reading is necessary. The work of Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson on institutions and capturing technological gains invites us to look at who benefits from the ambiguity of the definition.
The absence of distinctions between service levels in the legal definition can produce several effects. It can allow municipalities to declare formal compliance with a minimal service. It also deprives public authorities of the necessary levers to demand quality improvements: conditioning financing on a service level becomes difficult when the indicator does not establish this distinction. The imprecision of the definition can encourage the maintenance of minimal services and complicate investments in industrial supply chains.
The catadores, including those organized in cooperatives, play a strategic role in the Brazilian recycling chain and directly suffer its consequences. Their work is partly invisible in official statistics, precisely because informal channels do not correspond to any Sinisa category. Volumes of recovered materials are published in federal databases, even if their completeness may be limited and does not cover the entire informal chain.
Data governance as a condition for industrial financing
The issue is concrete for industrial actors. A recycling supply chain seeking to mobilize public or private financing must demonstrate a traceable material reserve, a measurable collection rate, and documented evolution over time. These three elements are particularly difficult to certify in territories where the two national databases diverge.
The restoration of the Everglades poses a structurally analogous problem: intermediate progress indicators (restored water, replanted surfaces) do not guarantee the final result. In Brazil, the declaration of the existence of selective collection does not guarantee that the service covers the entire municipal territory.
Several emerging economies are now working on frameworks for territorial certification of collection service levels. The idea: impose a taxonomy of services at three or four levels (voluntary drop-off without traceability, door-to-door collection without certified sorting, supply chain with partial traceability, supply chain with complete value chain certification) and condition financing on the certified level. This type of standard would make it possible, by 2035-2040, to render urban circularity objectives comparable between territories and financeable through green debt instruments or impact contracts. Ipea emphasizes the need to improve standardization and integration of information systems.
The concrete obstacles linked to this blind spot
Brazil has had a solid waste law since 2010. It sets mandatory selective collection obligations on municipalities, encourages recycling supply chains, and formally recognizes catador cooperatives. On paper, the normative framework is solid. On the ground, data divergences complicate the monitoring and diagnosis of the policy.
In Latin America, industrial automation dynamics are already modifying the structure of recovery supply chains in certain sectors. Recycling supply chains could benefit from these transformations, provided they have reliable databases on material flows to guide investments. Two national databases exist, but they provide contradictory information for 32.9% of the municipalities compared.
The blind spot has a measurable economic cost. Brazilian recycling supply chains process a fraction of potentially recoverable materials. The plastic recycling rate, for example, remains below potentials identified by sectoral studies; fragmented and poorly documented upstream collection complicates reliable industrial logistics.
The challenge exceeds technique. It engages trust between the federal state, municipalities, and industrial operators. An investor in a sorting-recovery unit needs to know, with a reasonable level of certainty, what material reserve they can secure on what territory. The absence of reliable data increases uncertainty and can discourage investment.
Building the measurement before building the supply chains
Ipea identifies a need for conceptual standardization and information integration between databases. This recommendation has the merit of pointing to the right problem: before multiplying collection points or financing additional sorting units, we must know what already exists and in what form.
Sinisa and Munic depend on different institutions: the Ministry of Cities for one, IBGE for the other. Their convergence requires an interministerial political decision, resources to update survey tools, and probably several years of transition before the new data series are long enough to be useful to decision-makers.
Several countries have followed this path. South Korea built a system for certifying recycling service levels by type of material and by territory starting in the 2000s. The European Union has been developing harmonized metrics for preparing for reuse and recycling for its member states since 2022. These experiences show that standardizing measurement is feasible, and that it systematically precedes jumps in material recovery rates.
The sequence remains to be decided. The effort to achieve statistical convergence between Sinisa and Munic can begin with an experiment on a sample of volunteer municipalities, without waiting for a high-level political agreement. Ipea documents the problem with sufficient precision for such an experiment to be launched today. The 1,837 municipalities in the gray zone constitute the most relevant field of inquiry: these are the territories where measurement is least reliable, and therefore where a common protocol would produce the most useful information.
Sources
- Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada (Ipea), « Resíduos sólidos e economia circular no Brasil: panorama da coleta seletiva » (2023), https://repositorio.ipea.gov.br/server/api/core/bitstreams/f53d1519-8e9c-48d5-b0d5-29a87d135e1e/content
- Diane Coyle, The Measure of Progress: Counting What Really Matters (Princeton University Press, 2025), https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691253336/the-measure-of-progress
- Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson, Power and Progress: Our Thousand-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity (PublicAffairs, 2023)
- Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE), Pesquisa de Informações Básicas Municipais (Munic)
- Sistema Nacional de Informações sobre Saneamento (Sinisa), Ministério das Cidades, Brasil



