Fire does not choose its victims at random. Jordan Thomas, a wildland firefighter who spent years holding defensive lines across North America, demonstrates this in When It All Burns with a clarity that climate reports struggle to achieve: behind every megafire lies a series of human decisions that made it possible, then inevitable. Published in hardcover and digital on May 27, 2025 by Riverhead Books, with a paperback edition on September 8, 2026, this book arrives as major metropolitan areas in the American West watch their insurers depart one by one.

The Essentials

  • Thomas argues that the intensity of modern megafires results less from warming alone than from decades of poor forest management and urbanization in exposed zones.
  • Some territories will remain defendable and insurable if concrete choices are made now; others are headed toward progressive uninhabitability.
  • The book rests on the author’s direct field experience, informed by land management data, hydrological studies, and analyses of forest policy.
  • In each chapter, Thomas identifies those responsible for decisions and the actors who bear the financial cost when fires strike.

A Firefighter Who Thinks Like a Geographer

Jordan Thomas does not write a firefighter’s memoir. He writes a book about territorial policy disguised as field narrative, and this is precisely what makes it useful.

His background: years spent on forest fires across North America, in frontline units where defensive lines are traced with tractors or by hand. This experience taught him something that climate models do not easily capture: two forests that burn do not burn the same way, and the difference rarely hinges on temperature alone. It hinges on the history of their management, the density of their fuel load, the presence or absence of preventive maintenance in the decades before the fire.

Thomas is not a climate skeptic. He accepts data on warming and prolonged droughts. But he refuses to let climate change absorb all responsibility. For him, warming is the match; human decisions are the fuel.

The Thesis: A Problem of Land Management as Much as Climate

The megafires of the American West are, according to Thomas, the product of a double accumulation that he develops across several chapters. Decades of total suppression policy, the “10 a.m. doctrine” aimed at extinguishing every fire before the next morning, eliminated low-intensity fires that naturally maintain forests. Forests became denser and loaded with dead fuel. At the same time, urbanization advanced into what American land planners call the wildland-urban interface (WUI), the contact zone between forest spaces and inhabited areas, where millions of people now live in houses built where fire has always passed through.

The result of this double accumulation is mechanical. When fire arrives—and Thomas insists on “when” rather than “if”—it finds dense fuel, houses without sufficient fire barriers, and potentially compromised evacuation routes. The catastrophe is the logical outcome of choices that seemed reasonable taken separately.

What makes the argument convincing is that it is geographically precise. Thomas does not speak of “the West” in general. He describes specific valleys, counties that maintained prescribed burning programs and others that abandoned them under pressure from residents. Zones where prescribed burning was maintained generally show lower fire severity in subsequent fires. The absence of fuel treatment can be associated with increased severity at the scale of affected areas.

The comparison is brutal and documented.

Insurability as a Political Indicator

One of the book’s most original contributions is reading the insurance crisis as a territorial signal rather than merely a financial problem.

Thomas observes what major reinsurers and insurance companies have begun to map: certain zones are no longer insurable at market rates. Companies do not disappear from ideology. They apply a loss probability they are asked to justify publicly to no one. State Farm suspended new homeowners insurance underwriting in California in 2023 without fully withdrawing from the state; Allstate had suspended new homeowners policies in 2022 without fully exiting either. These measures reflect a risk reassessment by insurers.

For Thomas, the insurers’ withdrawal is the moment of truth that land management had avoided producing. Federal wildfire fighting programs and subsidized post-disaster rebuilding probably kept populations in exposed zones, reducing market incentives to limit urbanization in these sectors. The insurer that leaves merely makes explicit the real cost that society had accepted bearing without saying so.

There is a political tension here that Thomas does not resolve, and he is right not to resolve too quickly. The people living in these zones are not all affluent owners who made an informed choice. Many are there for economic reasons: fire-risk zones were, until recently, also zones where housing prices were affordable. Abandoning these territories also means, in some cases, abandoning the most vulnerable households.

Prevention or Permanent Subsidy: Two Trajectories for Years to Come

Thomas structures a significant portion of his book around two possible trajectories, which proves useful for anyone working on land management policy.

One trajectory Thomas describes is planned withdrawal. Some states or counties could adopt rules conditioning rebuilding permits on updated fire-risk assessments. Zones classified as indefensible by official maps would be excluded from new permanent construction. Populations that leave would be supported toward other territories. Public wildfire fighting resources would concentrate on a reduced, defendable perimeter where preventive forest management practices are maintained.

This trajectory is politically difficult: it requires telling landowners their property will not be rebuilt.

Thomas designates another possible trajectory as “permanent perfusion.” In this trajectory, states would likely continue to subsidize reconstruction and insurance in exposed zones without changing urbanization rules. Each fire cycle would generate significant costs borne by all taxpayers. Territories would remain populated but, according to Thomas, dependent on recurrent public intervention to maintain their habitability. Thomas suggests this trajectory already characterizes some Western states and would pose budget problems over time.

Between these two trajectories lie levers that Thomas documents with precision. Thomas identifies large-scale prescribed burning—low-intensity fires deliberately set to consume dead fuel before extreme conditions arrive—as a major lever. Prescribed burning can reduce fire severity in treated zones, but the reduction in human and material losses is not established generally by cited data. The problem is that prescribed burning generates visible smoke for a few days, creating local opposition, and it crosses property boundaries that have no forest logic. A private owner refusing access to their parcel can be enough to interrupt preventive treatment over thousands of hectares.

Thomas proposes the idea of a pooled prevention fund that would finance prescribed burning and forest management independent of land regime, funded through budget reallocations. The idea is not new in specialized circles, but Thomas presents it with argumentative force that few works had managed before.

The question of water, flagged by the Associated Press in November 2026, adds a dimension that Thomas touches on but that deserves to be developed: megafires destroy watersheds and threaten water reserves for major urban areas. Cities that depend on burned forests for their water supply have more than a fire problem. They have a water problem. This considerably widens the perimeter of territories affected by forest management choices and strengthens Thomas’s argument for pooling prevention costs. This cascade degradation logic appears in African tropical forests, where the collapse of tree cover affects rainfall patterns far beyond directly affected zones.

Blind Spots in the Book

When It All Burns is a strong book, but it has limitations that honesty demands naming.

Thomas is very precise about the American West and much vaguer about what his conclusions imply for other geographies. Australian, Canadian, Mediterranean, or Siberian megafires follow different land management and property logic. Prescribed burning, for example, is well-documented in Australian Aboriginal forest management practice, with a body of results that would greatly enrich the argument. Thomas does not ignore this, but he does not really integrate it.

The social question remains underdeveloped. Thomas identifies the problem: risk zones were often affordable zones. He does not propose a serious political answer to rehousing modest-income households. Planned withdrawal is presented as the right trajectory, but “supporting populations toward other territories” is a formula that deserves elaboration: toward which territories, with what resources, and over what timeframe?

Finally, Thomas says little about economic actors who benefit from the status quo. Real estate developers selling houses in exposed zones, local elected officials whose tax base depends on these developments, companies lobbying against urbanization restrictions: these actors exist and weigh on political decisions. Naming them more explicitly would have strengthened the analysis of obstacles to planned withdrawal.

These limitations do not diminish the book’s value. They indicate directions the debate will need to take.

Reasons to Read It

When It All Burns does something rare in climate literature: it connects large aggregates—frequency of extreme fires, insurer withdrawal, public reconstruction costs—to concrete and local decisions that elected officials, land planners, and forest managers can or cannot make starting now.

This book addresses multiple audiences. Readers following climate policy who seek an entry point through adaptation rather than mitigation alone. Land management actors in France and elsewhere, where the question of habitability in fire-risk zones is beginning to pose itself with new urgency. Insurance economists and researchers working on the socialization of extreme risks. And, more broadly, anyone wanting to understand why megafires are not only a temperature problem but a governance problem—which is both more troubling and more encouraging.

On questions of adapting to ecosystem disruptions, work on coral reef restoration shows that deliberate, preventive human intervention can change trajectories we believed were fixed.

Cartographic data suggest that some territories are more vulnerable to fire while others remain defendable.


Bibliographic Information Title: When It All Burns: Fighting Fire in a Transformed World Author: Jordan Thomas Publisher: Riverhead Books (Penguin Random House) Publication date: May 27, 2025 (hardcover and digital); September 8, 2026 (paperback)


Sources

  1. Penguin Random House, bibliographic page for When It All Burns: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/722364/when-it-all-burns-by-jordan-thomas/
  2. Associated Press, Bigger and more-frequent wildfires threaten water supplies across the US, November 2026