France has deployed fiber at a speed that surprised Europe. In doing so, it has also created a financial time bomb in the territories that needed it most.

A network among Europe’s first, built in ten years

In less than fifteen years, fiber optic coverage in France reached more than 90%, compared to an average of 69% in the European Union by the end of 2024. As of December 31, 2024, France leads European countries with a coverage rate of 90%, ahead of Spain at 89%, the United Kingdom at 71%, Italy at 64%, and Germany at just 42%. A result no one expected so quickly in 2013, when the France Very High Speed Internet plan was launched with an initial target of 100% by 2022—a date since postponed several times.

Between 2010 and 2024, public authorities invested nearly 12.7 billion euros, with 8.7 billion carried by local authorities, 3.5 billion by the state, and 0.5 billion by the European Union. This coverage was achieved in parallel across urban and rural areas, with a level of private investment of nearly 35 billion euros representing at least 73% of total funding.

This overall figure masks two radically different models. In dense areas (major cities), private operators deployed with their own funds, where return on investment was guaranteed. For the rest of the territory, local authorities had to build it themselves.

A publicly-initiated network is fiber optic infrastructure financed by local authorities to cover areas considered unprofitable by private operators. It is a concrete response to reduce the digital divide separating dense urban areas from rural territories. These networks today cover nearly 70% of the territory and more than 40% of the population.

The fracture that persists beneath coverage figures

Among 44.6 million premises counted, 40.6 million are eligible for fiber optic connection, while 4 million remain to be made eligible. During the fourth quarter of 2024, deployment continued to slow, with a 32% decline compared to the fourth quarter of 2023.

These 4 million premises are not distributed at random. Despite investments made, 3% of the metropolitan population still lives in parts of the territory where no property is eligible for connection to the fiber network. But the national average masks striking disparities between regions.

In Brittany, the share of households that are not covered is particularly high: 21% of its residents live in white zone areas. In the Grand Est, the department of Moselle has 16% of its population in white zones, Meurthe-et-Moselle 10%. In Normandy, the department of Manche stands out for its backwardness, with 24%.

These zones have a specific social profile. In 200-meter grid cells where no property is eligible for fiber optic connection, 12.7% of households live below the poverty line—a rate significantly higher than the national average. The fracture is not only geographic.

It strikes populations that already have the least access to public services, healthcare, and administrative procedures. Due to the underrepresentation of young people and executives in rural territories, the population there is on average less comfortable with digital tools. Remote access for administrative procedures and medical teleconsultations cannot be used by the entire population.

The economic model of rural networks breaks just before the finish line

The problem is not deployment. It is what comes after.

Publicly-initiated networks, managed by local authorities in rural territories, are reaching the limits of their economic model, caught between operating costs that are too high and fiber subscriptions falling short of initial ambitions. 80% of publicly-initiated networks report operating costs higher than those of private areas, notably due to poorly adapted wholesale offerings, an explosion in civil works rental costs, surcharges related to network burial, and overrepresentation of fully underground cables.

In other words: the access tariffs that commercial operators pay to rural public networks were set more than ten years ago, based on economic models calibrated for dense areas. Compensation rates for connections are frozen at the national level for more than ten years and create an operating financial deficit in rural areas that threatens the financial balance of publicly-initiated networks.

The Court of Accounts, in its April 2025 report commissioned by the Senate finance committee, highlighted this imbalance. The result is a structural imbalance in the financing model of certain publicly-initiated networks, which argues for an update in 2025 of Arcep’s tariff guidelines. The Court emphasizes the risks to network quality and resilience. The outsourcing model to the commercial operator of final connections (the STOC mode) certainly allowed rapid penetration of fiber into households, but it presents several dysfunctions that lead to poor workmanship on networks, tangled cables, unjustified disconnections, and repeated internet outages for users.

And pressure is mounting. The dynamics of deployment in publicly-initiated areas rest on a fragile balance with heavy investments borne by local authorities, a level of connection points often more dispersed than expected, and commercialization that is losing steam. The minister in charge of digital affairs has explicitly designated this challenge as one of the five major challenges of the next digital decade.

Copper is fading, fiber takes on all the weight: by 2030

What transforms an economic model problem into a political urgency is the timeline for copper network closure. Orange is progressively dismantling ADSL, by batches of municipalities, between 2025 and 2030. Batch 2, comprising 829 municipalities, switched on January 27, 2026, and batch 3, with 2,138 municipalities, will close on January 31, 2027. The national commercial closure, initially scheduled for 2026, was postponed by one year because fiber coverage was not sufficiently advanced in certain rural areas.

The objective of fiber for all has been pushed back to 2030. In parallel, the copper ADSL network is gradually closing by zones and must disappear by 2030. The two timelines converge toward the same critical date. Where fiber will not be eligible in 2030, residents will lose their fixed internet connection without an alternative. And where public networks will have been poorly maintained due to insufficient revenue, service quality will degrade on the only remaining infrastructure.

This is not a theoretical scenario. Fiber deployment should reach 96% by the end of 2025, but the final kilometers prove to be the most complex: absence of existing infrastructure, high civil works costs, longer distances to cover. Result: an increase in costs, a degradation of the economic model of publicly-initiated networks, and pricing that has become obsolete for both operators and local authorities.

A national tariff equalization scheme or a second bill for territories

The break that needs to be made is tariff and institutional: not technical.

Today, Arcep sets wholesale access tariffs across the entire territory according to a uniform national grid. This grid makes sense in dense areas, where operating costs per connection point are low. It destroys rural networks, where these costs are three to four times higher. A rule change is expected to address the threat to the long-term financial balance of publicly-initiated networks. 80% of local authorities surveyed say the numbers don’t add up.

The lever exists and has been documented: replace uniform national pricing with a national equalization mechanism between dense and rural areas, financed by a contribution from private operators in their profitable zones and redistributed to deficit public networks. Elected officials’ associations have been alerting to this issue for several years without managing to bring all actors to the table to find solutions.

This change does not adjust a dial: it modifies who pays for the maintenance of a public utility infrastructure. Today, it is only the local taxpayers of rural territories. Tomorrow, an equalization fund would distribute this cost across the entire sector, including private operators who captured profitable zones without contributing to costly zones. The decision shifts who actually bears the long-term financial risk: the rural resident who has already funded the installation, or the sector whose overall profitability depends on the quality of the entire network.

Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson, in Power and Progress (2023), recall that infrastructure technologies only deliver on their promises if institutional rules actually distribute gains (and burdens) across the territory. Rural fiber optic in France illustrates this mechanism exactly: the infrastructure was built, the tariff framework did not follow, and gains were captured by dense areas while costs remained on isolated municipalities.

Technically, the Court of Accounts proposed as early as April 2025 an update to Arcep’s tariff guidelines. What has not been done is to make this update binding on operators and attach to it a binding equalization redistribution mechanism—not negotiated year by year in regulatory commissions.

The difference between the two: after a legislated equalization fund, a commercial operator can no longer refuse to contribute to the viability of networks it uses in rural areas. The system changes its financing base, and the digital divide ceases to be subsidized solely by the municipalities that suffer from it.

Sources

[1] Arcep, “High and Very High Speed Fixed Broadband Market: Q4 2024,” March 2025, https://www.arcep.fr/actualites/actualites-et-communiques/detail/n/marche-du-haut-et-du-tres-haut-debit-fixe-130325.html (accessed 29/09/2026).

[2] FTTH Council Europe, cited by Arcep, “Fiber Deployment in France,” October 2025, https://www.arcep.fr/actualites/actualites-et-communiques/detail/n/deploiement-de-la-fibre-en-france-281025.html (accessed 29/09/2026).

[3] Court of Accounts, “Public Support for Fiber Optic Deployment,” report, April 2, 2025, https://www.ccomptes.fr/fr/publications/les-soutiens-publics-en-faveur-du-deploiement-de-la-fibre-optique (accessed 29/09/2026).

[4] Senate, Finance Commission, “Follow-up to the Court of Accounts inquiry on public support for fiber optic,” report no. 510, April 2, 2025, https://www.senat.fr/rap/r24-510/r24-510_mono.html (accessed 29/09/2026).

[5] INSEE, “Unequal Access to Fiber Optic,” in Economy and Society in the Digital Age, 2025 edition, October 2025, https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/8616807?sommaire=8616883 (accessed 29/09/2026).

[6] INSEE, “Social and Economic Challenges of Digital Technology in an Increasingly Connected Society,” in Economy and Society in the Digital Age, 2025 edition, October 2025, https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/8616863?sommaire=8616883 (accessed 29/09/2026).

[7] Arcep, ARCOM, “Digital Usage Reference Framework: 4th Edition,” June 2024, https://www.arcep.fr (accessed 29/09/2026).

[8] Avicca, “Publicly-Initiated Networks: An Economic Model Under Pressure, at the Heart of the New Telecom Roadmap,” November 2025, https://www.frenchweb.fr/rip-un-modele-economique-sous-pression-au-coeur-de-la-nouvelle-feuille-de-route-telecom/458867 (accessed 29/09/2026).

[9] Acteurs publics, “Network Financing: Local Authorities Alert to an Overly Fragile Economic Model,” December 2025, https://acteurspublics.fr/articles/financement-des-reseaux-les-collectivites-alertent-sur-un-modele-economique-trop-fragile/ (accessed 29/09/2026).

[10] Orange / Arcep, Copper Network Closure Timeline, https://reseaux.orange.fr/fin-adsl-arret-cuivre/quand-calendrier-fermeture (accessed 29/09/2026).

[11] Arcep, “Fiber Optic Network Quality Observatory: 7th Edition (data through September 2025),” February 2026, https://www.arcep.fr/actualites/actualites-et-communiques/detail/n/reseaux-en-fibre-optique-190226.html (accessed 29/09/2026).

[12] Maire-Info, “Economic Balance of Networks and Communication on Copper Shutdown: Tomorrow’s Challenges for Territorial Digital Equality,” 2025, https://www.maire-info.com/article.asp?param=30794 (accessed 29/09/2026).

[13] Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, Power and Progress: Our Thousand-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity, Basic Books, 2023.

[14] OECD, Data on fiber subscriptions in member countries, https://www.oecd.org/sti/broadband (accessed 29/09/2026).