In Asia-Pacific, a growing number of people are now expected to access their social rights through a phone or administrative portal. The Asian Development Bank indicates it is engaged with the GIZ in nine countries in the region to strengthen digital social protection systems, showing that these systems present unequal levels of development and maturity across countries and their functions, due to a lack of suitable data infrastructure, governance, and financing. Behind the ambition to modernize social protection looms a more concrete risk: turning lack of connectivity or digital documentation into an automatic grounds for exclusion.
Key Points
- The digitalization of social aid can reduce delays and diversions, but without an explicit political framework, it creates invisible filters that exclude the people it was meant to protect.
- The Asian Development Bank finds that the spread of these systems remains concentrated in a limited number of countries and sectors. Essential infrastructure and capacities remain unevenly available across the region (ADB, 2026).
- Populations without reliable connectivity, without a digital identity document, or without administrative capacity are the first victims of poorly regulated dematerialization.
- Reducing this tension between digital efficiency and universal access requires deliberate political choices about maintaining analog pathways and human recourse.
- By 2035, the direction toward inclusive or exclusive digitalization will influence the actual effectiveness of social rights for a significant portion of the population.
The Promises of Digitalization and Its Real Beneficiaries
The argument for digitizing social aid is sound. The countries that have advanced furthest on this path—India with its Aadhaar biometric identity system, the Philippines with its beneficiary registries, Singapore with its integrated platforms—have managed to reduce processing times and limit diversions in certain contexts. In contexts where intermediaries were capturing a portion of transfers before they reached beneficiaries, direct payment to mobile accounts represented a real gain. Administrative efficiency is measurable, documented, and deserves to be named for what it is.
The problem emerges when you look at who actually benefits from these gains. Digitized systems work well for those who already have a phone, stable connectivity, an recognized identity document, and the capacity to navigate dematerialized administrative forms. This profile describes precisely those population segments that have the least need for social protection. Certain populations—informal workers in rural Indonesia, women without bank accounts in some provinces of Bangladesh, migrants without stabilized administrative status in Myanmar—experience no acceleration from digitalization. It adds a barrier.
The ADB concludes that the development, consolidation, and functionality of digital social protection systems vary strongly across the region. Essential infrastructure and capacities are lacking: reliable civil registries, interoperability systems between agencies, and financing models that would make it possible to maintain these platforms over time.
Digital Identity as a Condition for Entering Rights
The case of India illustrates both the potential and the limits of this dynamic. Aadhaar, the biometric identity system launched in 2010, has enrolled more than a billion people and made it possible to transfer government aid directly to bank accounts linked to identity. The savings on leaks and diversions have been substantial. But studies have documented that tribal populations, elderly people with degraded fingerprints, and people without stable addresses may encounter biometric authentication or enrollment obstacles and access issues related to identity or address proof. When biometrics fail, appeals procedures can present obstacles for people with limited administrative capacity.
This phenomenon has a name in the social protection literature: non-take-up. It refers to the share of people eligible for aid who do not access it, either because they are unaware they qualify or because the procedures exceed their capacities. Digitalization can reduce non-take-up for some and worsen it for others. Without systematic measurement of this gap by channel type—digital or physical—governments are flying blind. On the cognitive biases that lead populations to underestimate their eligibility, research on the perception of social policies shows that the problem predates digitalization, but it can amplify it brutally.
A right conditional on possessing digital equipment and digital competence loses its universal character. This question falls within political choices that administrations often avoid formulating explicitly, preferring to present digitalization as neutral modernization.
The Invisible Filters Babinet Anticipated
Gilles Babinet argues that the digital transformation of the state must be carried politically and accompanied by mediation, explanation, and arbitration. Without design guarantees, non-digital alternatives, and support, dematerialization can worsen unequal access. Digital systems carry the biases of their design, and these biases can disproportionately affect people with limited administrative capacity.
Without an explicit political framework, political responsibility dissolves when digital systems automatically exclude, without accessible human recourse. When an algorithm decides who is eligible and who is not, based on incomplete data or opaque criteria, political responsibility becomes diffuse. The excluded citizen has no identifiable interlocutor to contest the decision. In some Asia-Pacific contexts, digitized systems may operate without an accessible appeals mechanism.
Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson, in their work on technology and power, distinguish technologies that augment human capacities from those that substitute for or control them. A digital social aid system that replaces a corruptible human agent with transparent and traceable processing can improve beneficiaries’ situations. Digitalization becomes problematic when deployed without the safeguards that make it a technology of inclusion. This distinction is drawn country by country, program by program, depending on the presence or absence of these safeguards.
The technological acceleration observable in the region makes this question all the more urgent.
Lessons from Regional Experiences
Asia-Pacific offers an involuntary laboratory, because trajectories diverge sharply there. Singapore has built one of the world’s most integrated digital states, with public services accessible through a single identity and interoperable platforms. But Singapore is a high-income city-state with near-total mobile coverage and an administration with execution capacity unmatched in the region. Transposing this model to Cambodia or Laos without adapting the prerequisites amounts to importing the facade without the foundations.
The Philippines adopted a pragmatic approach with their unified registry of social aid beneficiaries, the Listahanan. The system made it possible to target the conditional cash transfers of the Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino program, one of the largest in Southeast Asia. Registry updates, however, lag, and households that have fallen into poverty since the last survey remain off the list until the next cycle. The digitalization of targeting made the data updating problem more visible, without solving it.
Bangladesh illustrates a third configuration. The country has massively deployed cash transfers via mobile money, with proven results on reducing delays and transaction fees. But women in rural areas, who represent a significant share of targeted beneficiaries, face mobile phone ownership rates substantially lower than those of men. The optimal digital channel for the system may be suboptimal for its priority beneficiaries.
By 2035: Two Paths, Two States
The Asian Development Bank and the United Nations judge that infrastructure decisions made now in the region will significantly influence the architecture of aid systems for decades to come. The registries being built today, the interoperability protocols being adopted or deferred, the physical counters being closed or maintained: none of this easily reopens.
Two trajectories are emerging. The first is inclusive digitalization, which conditions the deployment of digital tools on the maintenance of physical channels: counters with agents capable of supporting administrative procedures, appeals procedures accessible without digital equipment, processing times equivalent between digital and physical channels. Technology improves processing for those with connection and digital skills, while preserving access through physical channels. Costs are higher in the short term. Non-take-up could decrease.
The second trajectory is exclusive digitalization, where dematerialization advances as the path of least administrative resistance, without the investments in data infrastructure and governance that the Asian Development Bank deems essential. In this scenario, the absence of digital equipment or stable connectivity creates access obstacles to aid, due to lack of investment in data infrastructure and governance that the Asian Development Bank deems essential. The most vulnerable populations, whom social protection systems are supposed to reach first, most often precisely lack what the system requires to recognize them.
The most direct signal for distinguishing between these two trajectories is the non-take-up rate in low-connectivity zones, compared to well-covered zones. If this gap widens as digitalization advances, the system could progressively shift toward the second trajectory without formal decision. By 2035, where concentration of digital skills in major cities is already intensifying, this territorial gap could become structural.
Political Decisions to Make Before Technical Choices
The practical question is known. It is difficult to finance and maintain over time, not to formulate. Any digitized social provision should be accompanied by an enforceable right to treatment by physical means, with comparable processing time. Digital support agents—people capable of helping another person navigate the system—should be integrated into existing social protection structures in low-connectivity zones, not added at the margins as transitional devices.
These measures cost money and require recurring financing, beyond the initial investment in technological infrastructure. They also suppose that governments measure the efficiency of their systems not by the number of transactions processed, but by the proportion of eligible people who actually access them.
It is possible to be a builder of digital state and call for its regulation without contradiction. The digital transformation of social protection can be a tool of real inclusion. It does not become one by itself. It becomes one when politics sets rules before exclusion is established, not after. Asia-Pacific, with its diversity of trajectories and economies, still has the possibility to choose.
In ten years, some of these systems will be access infrastructure. Others will be filters. The difference lies in decisions being made now, about the counters kept open, the appeals made accessible, and the data agreed to be measured to know whether the system works for everyone.
Sources
- Asian Development Bank, Social Protection and Digitalization in Asia and the Pacific (2026), https://www.adb.org/publications/social-protection-digitalization-asia-pacific
- Gilles Babinet, Refondre les politiques publiques avec le numérique : Administration territoriale, État, citoyens, https://www.dunod.com/entreprise-et-economie/refondre-politiques-publiques-avec-numerique-administration-territoriale-etat
- United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, World Social Report, https://desapublications.un.org/file/22649/download
- Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson, Power and Progress: Our Thousand-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity, PublicAffairs, 2023



