On March 9, 2026, the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights adopted Resolution 654, calling on member states of the African Union to refrain from imposing blanket restrictions on digital content or platforms used by artists and creators. It opens an unprecedented normative undertaking: the development of a model law on artistic freedom for a continent of approximately 1.5 billion inhabitants.

The Essentials

  • Resolution 654 of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (March 9, 2026) calls on member states to refrain from blanket restrictions on digital platforms used by artists and requests the development of a continental model law.
  • The text recognizes that a state may limit artistic content in accordance with legality, necessity, and proportionality, but must refrain from blanket restrictions on platforms.
  • Sub-Saharan Africa experienced several dozen internet shutdowns or platform blockages during elections or crises between 2019 and 2025, according to data from the organization Access Now.
  • Recommendation systems can reduce the visibility of local creations or those from smaller markets, which may justify measures promoting discoverability and cultural diversity.
  • The resolution could remain without practical effect if the future model law is not developed and then adopted by states, but it provides neither an implementation timeline nor a mandatory transposition mechanism.

A distinction that African legislations had not yet drawn

For a long time, the question of online censorship was posed as a single issue: a state cut off the internet, or it did not. Resolution 654 addresses this differently. It recognizes that a state can only limit artistic content in accordance with legality, necessity, and proportionality. It calls on states to refrain from imposing blanket restrictions on digital content or platforms used by artists and creators.

This distinction seems obvious. It is not in practice. Between 2019 and 2025, the organization Access Now documented dozens of total internet shutdowns or platform blockages in Africa, triggered during contested elections, protests, or armed conflicts. Ethiopia, Cameroon, Sudan, Guinea, and Mali have all resorted to this technique. In each of these cases, artists, cultural journalists, and independent musicians distributing their work via YouTube, Instagram, or SoundCloud had their access cut without having committed any offense.

The resolution does not name these states. It constructs a rule. And therein lies its strength: a principle that applies to the future is worth more than an indictment of the past.

The construction of African artists in digital space

To understand what is at stake, one must look at what African creators have managed to build online over the past decade. Nigerian afrobeats, South African amapiano, Ivorian coupé-décalé, Senegalese rap: all these genres have broken through on a global scale largely because digital platforms eliminated traditional intermediaries. A producer in Lagos or Abidjan can now directly reach a listener in Paris, London, or Lagos without going through an international label.

UNESCO, in its 2026 report Re|Shaping Policies for Creativity, projects global revenue losses for music creators reaching up to 24% by 2028, linked to the anticipated impact of generative AI production. This figure measures a structural fragility: in certain African markets, the dominance of global platforms can affect the distribution and remuneration of artists, who do not benefit from the same contractual protections or the same legal recourse as their European or American counterparts.

The African resolution responds to this asymmetry. It protects artistic freedom and calls for avoiding blanket restrictions on digital platforms used by creators.

The algorithm as silent censor

This mechanism of algorithmic invisibility operates cumulatively. Content that does not cross the initial recommendation threshold receives fewer exposures, thus fewer plays, and thus even fewer recommendations. The circle reinforces itself without any explicit human decision ever being made. For an artist whose career depends entirely on revenue generated by platforms, the absence of visibility produces economic effects as real as an administrative ban. The distinction between state censorship and algorithmic marginalization then loses some of its practical relevance: in both cases, the work does not reach its audience and the creator receives no revenue.

The resolution calls on states to protect digital platforms used by artists against blanket restrictions, but does not specify how an artist can influence the conditions under which their work circulates within platforms. Protecting access is a necessary condition; it does not alter the internal logic of recommendation systems. The model law will therefore have to decide whether it stops at the platform’s border or whether it imposes obligations on private actors, which the current resolution does not directly constrain.

There exists a second form of exclusion, less visible than state shutdowns: that which platforms exercise themselves through their recommendation systems.

Bruno Patino, director of Arte and author of Submersion, has theorized this mechanism with precision. The engagement algorithms that govern YouTube, TikTok, or Spotify are not neutral. They optimize time spent on the platform, which pushes them to favor content that creates addiction: the ultra-stimulating, the familiar, the already-seen. In this model, a song by Burna Boy that already has ten million plays will be recommended endlessly; a musician from Ouagadougou who publishes their first album, even if excellent, remains invisible for lack of having passed the initial virality threshold.

Global platforms algorithmically ignore African local creations rather than suppressing them. The effect on cultural diversity is comparable to censorship, without any official signing a ban order. This tension between platform access and algorithmic control of content is part of the broader debate about who decides, in practice, what deserves to be seen. The result is progressive homogenization.

Resolution 654 does not directly address this problem. It protects access, not visibility. But it lays the first stone: without guaranteed access, the debate on algorithmic visibility becomes secondary.

A liberal reading that merits consideration

Any continental norm carries with it a reverse risk. In seeking to protect freedom of expression, it can create conditions for platform regulation by states, with all the abuse that entails.

This tension runs through global digital law. Economists like Luigi Zingales, defenders of market liberal thought, emphasize that well-intentioned regulation can backfire against those it aims to protect. If an African model law defines which content can be moderated and which cannot, its implementation will fall either to an African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights with limited resources, or to governments that were cutting off the internet three years ago.

The resolution itself takes this risk into account. It calls for a ban on blanket restrictions, not a ban on all moderation. It calls on states to refrain from imposing blanket restrictions on digital content or platforms. This distinction follows in the line of the Johannesburg Principles on National Security and Freedom of Expression. As early as 1995, these principles framed restrictions on expression invoked in the name of national security with requirements of legality, necessity, and the least restrictive means.

The model law has not yet been drafted. Its drafting will bring together two logics: that of artists, who demand access, and that of states, who want control.

A state can formally adopt the model law while maintaining in its domestic law provisions that allow, under other qualifications, restrictions on platform access. Without an explicit supremacy clause or without an independent oversight mechanism, compliance of appearance becomes a convenient exit.

The problems the model law must solve to keep its promises

Three concrete questions await the drafters of the future model law.

The first is that of the appeals mechanism. Today, when a platform removes a work or a state blocks a service, the artist generally has no identified contact. A fast-track contestation procedure is the minimum condition for the proclaimed right to become an exercised right.

The second is how it articulates with national laws. Fifty-four member states, fifty-four different legal frameworks. The resolution calls for a model law, not a uniform law. The future model law is designed to guide member states in aligning their national legislation. Some will do it quickly, others never.

Experience with previous African resolutions on online expression, whose transposition rates remain low, invites caution.

The third is that of the platforms themselves. The resolution addresses states. But the major decisions on moderation, recommendation, and access are made by private companies headquartered in San Francisco, Beijing, or Amsterdam. Any model law that ignored platform obligations would protect artists only halfway.

UNESCO, in its 2026 report on cultural policies, specifically calls for mechanisms that bring together states, platforms, and creators’ organizations. The African resolution can become the lever to launch these triangular negotiations, if states seize the opportunity.

To these three questions is added a fourth, more structural one: the hierarchy of norms. In several African national legal systems, continental treaties and resolutions are not automatically superior to ordinary laws. This risk is documented in other areas of continental law, where formal transposition has endured alongside practices contrary to the spirit of the text.

The model law will therefore need to not only define substantive obligations, but also specify how an artist or creators’ organization can invoke these obligations before a national court, without having to wait for a continental body to take up the case. It is on this condition that protection ceases to be declaratory to become operational.

A continental precedent that looks beyond Africa

Resolution 654 arrives at a moment when other regions are still seeking their own legal vocabulary on these questions. The European Union has built the most developed framework with the Digital Services Act and the copyright directive. The United States remains divided. Southeast Asia has no comparable regional framework.

In asserting that artistic expression is a form of communication protected by freedom of expression, Africa takes an angle that other legal systems have often neglected. The artist is also an economic actor whose income depends on continuous access to digital spaces. Protecting this access amounts to protecting an entire sector.

This logic aligns with what progress studies document about the material conditions of cultural creation: the diversity of expressions does not survive on the good will of creators alone. It needs infrastructure, rules, and markets that do not crush it. In this sense, the African resolution makes a contribution that lawmakers on other continents will have reason to study.

The next step is decisive. The African Commission must launch the process of drafting the model law by dialoguing with states and other stakeholders, otherwise the text risks remaining a statement of intent. Previous African precedents in other areas of law, the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights adopted in 1981, ratified slowly, applied even more slowly, show that the passage from text to practice takes time. But they also show that a continental norm, even imperfectly applied, gradually changes what is politically acceptable. That is already a great deal.


Sources

  1. African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Resolution 654 on Artistic Freedom, March 9, 2026, https://achpr.au.int/fr/adopted-resolutions/654-achprres654lxxxvi-2026
  2. UNESCO, Re|Shaping Policies for Creativity 2026, https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/creators-face-projected-global-revenue-losses-24-2028-new-unesco-report-shows
  3. Bruno Patino, Submersion, MUCEM, https://mucem.org/notice/b/oai%3APMB%3A151267/
  4. Access Now, #KeepItOn: Report on Internet Shutdowns in Africa 2019-2025, Access Now (unverified link)
  5. Johannesburg Principles on National Security, Freedom of Expression and Access to Information, 1995, Article 19